Most entrepreneurs come to us with the same question: "should I set up an LLC or a sole proprietorship?" It's a good question, but it often comes too early, or too late. Too early, because you spend CHF 2,000 to 3,000 of incorporation costs on an LLC before having a single client. Too late, because you stay a sole proprietor while already making CHF 150,000 of profit, paying thousands of francs too much in tax every year, and exposing your house and savings. The real question is not only "which form?", but "when, at what revenue and at what profit?". That is what this article breaks down, with figures and tables.
The 3 figures to know by heart
Before comparing legal forms, remember these three thresholds. They structure the whole decision.
| Threshold | What it triggers | Form concerned |
|---|---|---|
| CHF 100,000 revenue | Mandatory VAT registration + mandatory entry in the Commercial Register | Sole proprietorship |
| CHF 500,000 revenue | Obligation to keep full commercial accounts (double-entry) | Sole prop. (LLC from the 1st franc) |
| ~CHF 80,000 to 120,000 net profit | Zone where moving to an LLC generally becomes tax-advantageous | Switch sole prop. to LLC |
The first two are legal obligations. The third is a decision zone: there is no official threshold for "becoming an LLC", it is an economic trade-off.
Step 1: when do you need to create "a structure" at all?
Many confuse "starting a business" with "setting up an LLC". As soon as you invoice a service in your own name, on a lasting basis, you already carry out a self-employed activity, you are in effect a sole proprietorship, even without having formally "created" anything. At this stage, what matters is not the legal form but your social-insurance status: you must register with an AVS compensation fund as self-employed and have this status recognised; as long as your revenue stays below CHF 100,000, there is no obligation to register in the Commercial Register or for VAT; and the sole proprietorship costs almost nothing to set up, with no capital, no notary.
In short: to start and validate a project, you don't set up an LLC, you launch a sole proprietorship. The "heavy" structure comes later.
The big comparison: sole proprietorship vs LLC
| Criterion | Sole proprietorship | LLC (Sarl) |
|---|---|---|
| Start-up capital | None | CHF 20,000 minimum |
| Set-up costs | ~CHF 0 to 700 | ~CHF 2,000 to 3,000 (notary + register + publication) |
| Liability | Unlimited on all private assets | Limited to the share capital |
| Commercial Register | Mandatory from CHF 100,000 revenue | Mandatory from incorporation |
| Legal personality | No: you are the business | Yes: separate entity |
| Accounting | Simplified if revenue < CHF 500,000 | Double-entry from the 1st franc |
| Director's status | Self-employed | Employee of their company |
| Social contributions | AVS ~10%; no unemployment; LPP optional | Shared; unemployment covered; LPP from CHF 22,680 |
| Profit taxation | Added to income, progressive scale | Company + dividend (partial taxation) |
| Salary/dividend | Not possible | Yes (main tax lever) |
| Partners / investors | Not possible | Yes, several partners |
| Sale / transfer | Difficult (tied to the person) | Easy (sale of shares) |
Criterion 1: liability (the most underestimated)
This is by far the most important difference, and the one people most regret not anticipating. In a sole proprietorship, there is no separation between you and the business. A debt, a lawsuit or bankruptcy engages your private assets: savings, car, even your home. In an LLC, the company is a separate legal person. In case of bankruptcy, creditors are in principle repaid from the company's assets. Your private assets are protected.
Three honest caveats, the LLC is not a magic shield: 1) banks and landlords often require a personal guarantee from the manager; 2) in case of management fault or unpaid contributions, your personal liability can be engaged; 3) the CHF 20,000 capital must remain genuine working capital.
Simple rule: the more risk your activity carries (stock, large investments, debts, major contracts), the earlier the LLC is justified. A consulting activity with no stock or debt can stay a sole proprietorship far longer.
Criterion 2: social contributions
This is the most misunderstood criterion, because it cuts both ways.
| Contribution | Sole proprietorship | LLC (manager-employee) |
|---|---|---|
| AVS / AI / APG | ~10% of profit (degressive on low income) | 10.6% of salary (5.3% employee / 5.3% employer) |
| Unemployment (AC) | No cover | Covered |
| LPP (2nd pillar) | Optional | Mandatory from CHF 22,680 of salary |
| LAA (accident) | To take out yourself | Mandatory |
In a sole proprietorship, lighter contributions at the start, but you are less protected. In an LLC, you pay more, but the cover is better and the LPP becomes a powerful tax tool: contributions and above all buy-ins are deductible.
Not to overlook: a well-earning self-employed person with no 2nd pillar builds a "time bomb" for their retirement. The switch to an LLC is often the chance to fill these gaps.
Criterion 3: taxation (where the money hides)
As a sole proprietorship: everything goes into your income
The profit is added to your private income and taxed on the progressive scale. As long as the profit is modest, this is advantageous. When it climbs, progressivity bites hard: in some cantons the marginal rate exceeds 40%.
As an LLC: two levels, but a lever
The LLC is taxed on its profit. What you pay yourself is then taxed in your hands: the salary as income, the dividends with partial taxation, for a qualified holding (10% or more), only 70% of the dividend is taxed at federal level (the cantonal share varies). The dividend is not subject to social contributions. This is the salary/dividend trade-off: setting a reasonable salary and a lighter-taxed dividend to optimise the overall burden. This trade-off does not exist in a sole proprietorship.
| Sole prop. profit 60k | Sole prop. profit 150k | LLC profit 150k | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxation | All as income | All as income, strong progressivity | Salary + lighter dividend |
| Social contributions | ~10% on everything | ~10% on everything | On the salary only |
| Smooth the result | No | No | Yes (reserve in the company) |
| Verdict | Sole prop. ideal | Sole prop. disadvantageous | LLC wins |
The conclusion is almost always the same: at low profit, the sole proprietorship wins; at high profit, the LLC takes the advantage. The tipping point lies between CHF 80,000 and CHF 120,000 of net annual profit.
So, when to create what?
Create (or stay) a sole proprietorship if...
- You are starting out and still validating your activity.
- Your profit is below ~CHF 80,000-100,000.
- Your activity carries little risk.
- You want minimal costs and administration.
- You are alone, with no partner.
Create an LLC directly if...
- Your activity is risky from the outset.
- You start with several people or with an investor.
- You expect high profit quickly.
- Image and asset separation matter from launch.
- You want to be able to sell or transfer easily.
Switch from sole proprietorship to LLC when...
- Your profit durably exceeds ~CHF 100,000.
- Your risk rises (staff, large contracts).
- You want to protect substantial private assets.
- You want to structure your pension.
| Profile / level | Typical recommendation |
|---|---|
| Launch, revenue < 100k, low profit | Sole proprietorship |
| Revenue 100k-500k, profit < ~80k, low risk | Sole prop. (with VAT + register) |
| Profit ~80k-120k | Tipping zone, case by case |
| Profit > 120k, high risk or partners | LLC |
The switch from sole proprietorship to LLC: how it works
You don't "break" your business. The transfer is done via the Merger Act (LFus), by contributing the individual business into the new company.
- Possible tax neutrality: hidden reserves can be transferred without immediate taxation if the business is taken over at its book value and remains taxable in Switzerland.
- 5-year lock-up: do not sell your shares within 5 years, on pain of a back tax assessment.
- Retroactive effect: the operation can often be backdated up to 6 months.
- Pension: you become an employee, so affiliated to the LPP, the chance to fill gaps with deductible buy-ins.
What does it really cost?
| Item | Sole proprietorship | LLC |
|---|---|---|
| Capital to lock up | CHF 0 | CHF 20,000 (remains an asset) |
| Set-up | CHF 0 to ~700 | ~CHF 2,000 to 3,000 |
| Annual accounting | Lighter (if < 500k) | Double-entry, higher |
| Returns | 1 (private + schedule) | Company + private return |
The LLC costs more to set up and to run. This extra cost is only justified when the tax saving, asset protection or need for partners offsets it.
Common mistakes (seen in practice)
- Setting up an LLC too early, with no revenue: CHF 20,000 locked up and disproportionate costs.
- Staying a sole proprietorship too long: at 150k of profit, you "gift" thousands of francs to the tax office.
- Forgetting the pension: a self-employed person with no 2nd pillar prepares a retirement hole.
- Paying yourself too low a salary in an LLC: risk of AVS reclassification.
- Underestimating the liability of a sole proprietorship, until the first unpaid bill.
In summary
The sole proprietorship is ideal to start, test and while profits stay modest. The LLC takes the advantage as soon as your profit durably exceeds ~CHF 80,000-120,000, your risk rises, you start with several people, or asset protection becomes a priority. The right reflex: reassess every year your revenue, your profit and your risk exposure.
Unsure about the right moment? At NeoFidu, we analyse your actual situation, revenue, profit, canton, risk, pension, and tell you frankly whether the sole proprietorship still suffices or whether the LLC would save you money. Request a free assessment, no obligation.
This article is provided for information and does not constitute individualised legal or tax advice. Thresholds and rates reflect the law in 2026 and vary by canton. Official sources: the Confederation's SME portal (kmu.admin.ch), the Federal Tax Administration (estv.admin.ch), the ch.ch portal.