neofidu.ch
Should You Request a TOU in Geneva? When It Makes You Lose Money
Taxation

Should You Request a TOU in Geneva? When It Makes You Lose Money

The TOU is not always worthwhile and the request is irrevocable. Worked examples with the federal tax calculator, favourable cases and pitfalls, and a method to decide before 31 March 2027.

7 min read

On cross-border worker forums, the TOU is often presented as a reflex: "request it, you'll get money back". Sometimes that is true, but not always. And the mistake is costly: once filed, a TOU request cannot be withdrawn, even if the assessment turns out unfavourable.

Here is how to know, before signing, whether a subsequent ordinary assessment (TOU, « taxation ordinaire ultérieure ») will make you gain or lose money.

In short: the TOU pays off if you have deductions that the source-tax scale ignores (pillar 3a, pension buy-ins, childcare, maintenance for minor children, training). Without them, it brings nothing. With a spouse employed in France, it is usually not even available. Deadline for 2026 income: 31 March 2027.

What the TOU changes

Taxed at source, you pay according to a scale that already includes flat-rate deductions (professional expenses, insurance premiums). With the TOU, you are taxed like a Geneva resident, on a full tax return, with your actual deductions. For a non-resident, the tax rate takes the household's worldwide income into account.

So the real question is not "do I have deductions?" but: are my deductions outside the scale large enough for the ordinary tax to be clearly lower?

Three worked examples

We calculated the 2026 ordinary tax with the official calculator of the Federal Tax Administration (AFC/ESTV), in the city of Geneva, without church tax, for a single person with a gross salary of CHF 90,000. The difference between the tax without and with the deductions gives the order of magnitude of the TOU gain.

SituationDeductions outside the scale2026 ordinary taxEstimated saving
No additional deductionCHF 0CHF 12,764CHF 0
Maximum pillar 3aCHF 7,258CHF 10,856about CHF 1,900
Pillar 3a + CHF 20,000 pension buy-inCHF 27,258CHF 5,647about CHF 7,100

NeoFidu calculation of 18 November 2026 with the AFC calculator (swisstaxcalculator.estv.admin.ch). As the source-tax scale is flat-rate, the actual saving may differ from this estimate.

When the TOU is usually worthwhile

  • You pay the maximum into pillar 3a (CHF 7,258 in 2026), a deduction missing from the scale.
  • You made a pension fund (LPP) buy-in: often the most profitable case, as a large buy-in sharply reduces the year's taxable income.
  • Your children are in third-party care (nursery, after-school care, childminder), with invoices.
  • You pay maintenance for minor children.
  • You pay for your own professional training.

When the TOU may cost you

1. You have hardly any additional deduction

Without pillar 3a, buy-in or childcare, the TOU gives you nothing more than the scale. The result can even be worse, and you will have filed a return for nothing.

2. Your spouse works in France

This is the most common case. To be a quasi-resident, at least 90% of the household's worldwide gross income must be taxable in Switzerland. Example: a CHF 80,000 Geneva salary and the equivalent of CHF 14,000 of French salary for the spouse give about 85%: the TOU on request is not open. Also watch out for a spouse working in another border canton, for example in the canton of Vaud: taxed in France under the 1983 agreement, their salary lowers the Swiss share.

3. Your household has other income outside Switzerland

Rent or other income received in France counts in the 90% calculation and in the tax rate. It can cost you the status or reduce the gain.

4. You forget it must be repeated every year

In Geneva, a quasi-resident's TOU on request must be renewed every year before 31 March. A favourable year, for example thanks to a pension buy-in, says nothing about the next one: redo the calculation every year.

The right method: calculate before filing

  1. Check the 90% threshold with both spouses' income.
  2. List your deductions outside the scale: pillar 3a, pension buy-ins, childcare, maintenance, training.
  3. Compare the estimated ordinary tax with the source tax withheld on your payslips.
  4. File only if the difference is clearly in your favour, by 31 March of the following year.

Your Swiss salary is still declared in France (form 2047-Suisse), whether or not you request a TOU.

Your situationTOU?
Maximum pillar 3a and/or pension buy-inOften worthwhile
Children in third-party careOften worthwhile
No deduction outside the scaleRarely useful
Spouse employed in FranceUsually not available (90% threshold)
Significant income outside SwitzerlandCalculate carefully
31 March is a hard deadline. After it, the year's source tax becomes final. If you are still waiting for documents, file the request first, then complete the file.

Do the maths before committing

Our TOU calculator estimates your gain for free with the official AFC calculator. For an opinion on your case, we offer a TOU analysis at CHF 240, deducted from the full package at CHF 390 (analysis, request and tax return). If the TOU is not in your favour, we tell you, and you only pay for the analysis.

Further reading: our Geneva TOU service, the GeTax guide on source tax and the quasi-resident cross-border worker guide.

General information for the 2026 tax year, not individual advice. Sources: Geneva cantonal tax administration (ge.ch), Federal Tax Administration.

Optimisez votre fiscalité avec NeoFidu

Un spécialiste diplômé prend en charge votre déclaration d’impôts de A à Z. Dès CHF 89.-

Related articles