Choosing accounting software when you start a sole proprietorship (raison individuelle) or a small Sàrl (GmbH) is often a choice for several years. Switching later costs time, and price gaps are large: for the same need, the annual bill ranges from CHF 0 to more than CHF 800. We compared the six solutions most widely used in French-speaking Switzerland: Banana, bexio, Crésus, AbaNinja, CashCtrl and KLARA.
What the law requires: sole proprietorship or Sàrl
Before comparing software, you need to know which bookkeeping you must keep:
- Sole proprietorship with turnover below CHF 500,000: simplified bookkeeping is enough, i.e. income, expenses and a statement of assets (art. 957 para. 2 CO). A well-kept spreadsheet is legally possible, but software makes the job much easier.
- Sàrl: full double-entry commercial accounts, with balance sheet, income statement and notes (art. 957 para. 1 and 958 ff. CO), whatever the turnover.
- Retention: books and supporting documents must be kept for 10 years (art. 958f CO). Check that you can export your data if you leave a cloud tool.
- VAT: registration becomes mandatory from CHF 100,000 in annual turnover (art. 10 VAT Act). You then have to file regular VAT returns.
- Payroll: in a Sàrl, the managing partner is usually an employee of the company. That means payslips, AVS (social security) returns and an annual salary certificate.
To know when to move from a sole proprietorship to a Sàrl, read our article Sole proprietorship or Sàrl: when to set up a company?.
The criteria that really matter
- Bank import (ISO 20022 format, camt files) or a direct bank connection: this is the biggest time saver.
- VAT: does the software calculate the official return and can it submit it as XML to the Federal Tax Administration?
- QR-bill: essential for invoicing in Switzerland.
- Payroll: an integrated module, ideally Swissdec-certified to transmit data to social insurers.
- Cloud or installed software: the cloud makes sharing with your fiduciary easier; installed software works offline and is often cheaper.
- Users and volume limits: users included, entries, documents or payslips per plan.
Published prices compared (November 2026)
| Software | Type | Entry plan | Plan suited to a small business | Payroll | Key points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Banana Accounting Plus | Installed software (Windows, Mac, Linux), mobile app | Free: limited to 70 entries Professional: CHF 89 / year | Advanced: CHF 179 / year | No payroll module | Excellent value; ISO 20022 import from Professional; official VAT return and XML export in Advanced only |
| bexio | Cloud | Basic: CHF 35 / month (annual contract, excl. VAT), 1 user, no e-banking | Advanced: CHF 42 / month, 2 users, e-banking Optima: CHF 69 / month, 5 users | Add-on from CHF 7 / month (1 employee) or CHF 25 / month (5 employees) | Full business management (quotes, invoices, accounting); new plans and prices in 2026 |
| Crésus Comptabilité | Installed software, hosting possible via Crésus Cloud | Rental: CHF 20 / month excl. VAT Purchase: CHF 600 excl. VAT + Crésus+ CHF 120 / year | Same product, paid options (cost accounting) | Crésus Salaires: rental CHF 15 / month excl. VAT (up to 5 employees) | Widely used by French-speaking fiduciaries; each module (invoicing, payroll) is paid separately |
| AbaNinja | Cloud | Starter: free, 1 user, 1,000 documents a year | Basic: CHF 21 / month, 3 users Pro: CHF 49 / month, 5 users | Included, limited per plan (1, 7 or 21 payroll runs) | Abacus technology; bank connection and QR-bills in every plan |
| CashCtrl | Cloud | FREE: 1 user, no bank import or attachments | PRO: approx. CHF 350 / year incl. VAT, prepaid (6, 12 or 24 months) | Included in PRO | True double entry even in the free plan; interface aimed at accounting rather than sales |
| KLARA | Cloud | Business Basic: CHF 55 / month (annual contract) | Business Plus: CHF 79 / month Premium: CHF 127 / month | Optional module | Designed for shops (till, online shop, bookings); no free plan |
Simulation: what does a year of bookkeeping cost?
Profile 1: self-employed sole proprietor
A consultant not registered for VAT, about 300 entries a year, no employees, wanting QR-bills and bank statement import. Estimated annual cost of the cheapest plan covering that need:
| Software | Estimated annual cost | Plan |
|---|---|---|
| AbaNinja | CHF 0 | Starter (1,000 documents a year) |
| Banana | CHF 89 | Professional |
| Crésus | CHF 240 excl. VAT | Comptabilité, rental |
| CashCtrl | approx. CHF 350 | PRO (FREE is free but has no bank import) |
| bexio | CHF 504 excl. VAT | Advanced (Basic at CHF 420 has no e-banking) |
| KLARA | CHF 660 | Business Basic |
Profile 2: small Sàrl
A Sàrl registered for VAT, a salaried managing partner and one employee, monthly payroll, invoices issued from the software:
| Software | Estimated annual cost | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| AbaNinja | CHF 252 to 588 | Basic or Pro depending on the number of payroll runs |
| CashCtrl | approx. CHF 350 | PRO, payroll included |
| Banana + Crésus Salaires | CHF 359 | Banana Advanced CHF 179 + Crésus Salaires rental CHF 180 excl. VAT |
| Crésus | CHF 420 excl. VAT | Comptabilité CHF 240 + Salaires CHF 180 (rental) |
| bexio | CHF 804 excl. VAT | Advanced CHF 42 + payroll up to 5 employees CHF 25, per month |
| KLARA | from CHF 660 + payroll module | Business Basic + payroll add-on |
These are orders of magnitude. For Crésus, invoicing is a separate module (rental CHF 20 a month excl. VAT) if you want to issue invoices in the same tool. For bexio and KLARA, the price also covers quotes, contacts and invoicing, which the other solutions cover less completely.
Which software for which profile?
- Just starting, few transactions, zero budget: AbaNinja Starter, or CashCtrl FREE if you are happy to enter bank transactions by hand.
- Sole proprietorship wanting a lasting, inexpensive tool: Banana Professional. It handles both income-and-expense and double-entry bookkeeping, and most French-speaking fiduciaries can read it.
- VAT-registered: Banana Advanced to produce the official return, or a cloud solution that includes it.
- Small Sàrl wanting payroll and invoicing in one tool: bexio, AbaNinja or CashCtrl PRO.
- Windows user, or fiduciary already on Crésus: Crésus, a French-speaking Swiss standard for decades.
- Shop with a till or online store: KLARA, whose strength this is.
Pitfalls to avoid
- Excluding or including VAT: compare like with like. The 8.1% VAT can change the ranking between two close offers.
- Plan changes: bexio renamed and repriced its packages in 2026, and existing subscriptions move to the new prices at renewal.
- Volume limits: 70 entries in Banana Free, 1,000 documents a year in AbaNinja Starter, number of employees in Crésus Salaires. Growth can force a plan change.
- Data export: with a cloud tool, check how you retrieve your entries and documents after cancelling. You must be able to produce them for 10 years.
- Software does not close the books: depreciation, provisions, accruals and profit allocation remain accounting work. Good software used badly produces wrong accounts. See also the 10 costly accounting mistakes.
Is the software tax-deductible?
Yes. The subscription or licence for software used in your business is a justified business expense. It is deductible from the self-employment income of a sole proprietorship and from the taxable profit of a Sàrl, for federal direct tax as well as cantonal and communal tax.
Frequently asked questions
Is an Excel spreadsheet enough for a sole proprietorship?
Legally, yes, as long as your simplified bookkeeping is complete and documented. In practice, without bank import or automatic checks, mistakes are common and VAT quickly becomes painful. A free solution such as AbaNinja Starter or CashCtrl FREE is often safer.
Can I switch software during the year?
It is possible, but the simplest is to switch on 1 January, carrying over the opening balance sheet. Otherwise you have to re-enter or import every entry of the current year.
What happens when I turn my sole proprietorship into a Sàrl?
The Sàrl is a new legal entity: it has its own accounts, starting on its incorporation date. You can keep the same software by opening a new file or company, but check that your plan allows several companies if you run both in parallel during the transition.
Should I pick my fiduciary's software?
It is not mandatory, but it is often more efficient: fewer exports, less re-entry and lower fees. Ask your fiduciary which tools they work with before subscribing.
NeoFidu keeps the books of self-employed people and small Sàrl in the canton of Vaud and across French-speaking Switzerland, in Banana by default or directly in your bexio. Our Indépendant and PME packages are detailed on our pricing page. Not sure which tool fits? Contact us and we will advise you based on your business.
Informational article, up to date as of November 2026; it does not constitute personalised advice. Prices quoted are the base prices published by the vendors and may change without notice. Sources: pricing and feature pages of Banana.ch, bexio, AbaNinja (DeepCloud AG); Crésus price list (Epsitec SA) as of 12.12.2025; CashCtrl PRO price as reported by Makerstack and Pfeffersack; KLARA prices as reported by Magic Heidi (July 2026); Swiss Code of Obligations (art. 957 to 958f); VAT Act (art. 10).